I AGREE with 99 per cent of Ian Epstein's letter on animal cruelty.
However, it appears that, sadly, over the centuries there has been
some sort of inconsistency by the interpreters of the Torah (unless
I may be just naïve about it).
The sixth commandment - thou shalt not murder - and the commandment
in the book of Jeremiah that thou shalt not hurt nor destroy in
all of my holy mountain seems to be left out when appertaining to
following a vegetarian/vegan diet. (To set the record straight,
Adam and Eve were vegans, not vegetarians.)
If you study the text in detail, I am sure your columnist Rabbi
Chaim Kanterovitz would confirm this.
There is no commandment whatsoever to eat meat, but there is reluctant
permission, as written in Genesis.
As it is written many times in the Shulchan Aruch, one should
adhere to the stricter rule of Torah. Following a vegetarian/vegan
diet is not advocated but skipped over by any beth din or religious
authority.
I believe that following a vegetarian/vegan diet constitutes a
mitzva. That would be one step nearer to the coming of Moshiach.
I very much doubt if the Chief Rabbi, Sir Jonathan Sacks, would
disagree with my hypothesis.
S Miller,
Cheetham,
Manchester.
E-MAIL: letters@jewishtelegraph.com
Full names and addresses must accompany letters and will be published
unless correspondents specify otherwise.